The overall experience at Goodlife South Melbourne seems to be quite mixed based on the reviews provided. While some members praise the gym for its range of equipment, helpful staff, and excellent trainers, others express disappointment in the handling of serious incidents of racism, overcrowding, cleanliness issues, and outdated facilities.

Concerns about membership flexibility, cleanliness, and equipment availability seem to be recurring themes, with some members considering switching to other gyms. However, positive feedback regarding certain classes and trainers suggests that there are aspects of the gym that are still highly valued by members.

In conclusion, the overall experience at Goodlife South Melbourne appears to be a combination of both positive and negative aspects, with room for improvement in various areas.